It is well known that 529 plans are the best way to save for your child’s higher education expenses. 77% of parents who are saving for their child’s college expenses are using a 529 plan, according to the College Saving Survey by Savingforcollege.com. And with over 80% of parents wanting to pay for at least 50% of their student’s expenses, we all want to be prepared and start saving early. But what happens to your 529 savings if your child doesn’t go to college? Does a 529 plan make sense if you don’t know what your child’s future will hold?
Not all 529 plans are created equal and what is best for your family may depend on where you live. Check out this post on choosing the best 529 college savings plan to make sure you are getting the most bang for your buck!
Remember that any higher education expenses count
When it comes to using a 529 plan, it isn’t just for a four-year college degree. 529 plans can be used for associates degrees, trade and vocational school, online colleges and graduate degrees. If your child wants to go to beauty school, become a mechanic, or train to be a world-class chef, chances are there are programs at home and abroad that are eligible for 529 spending.
If your child wants to start a business, you could recommend they take some courses at the local community college. They don’t have to pursue a full four-year degree, but a few business, risk management, and accounting classes will get them off on the right foot and generate some qualified expenses for that 529 plan.
Just because they are college age, doesn’t mean the money has to be withdrawn now
Plans change, especially for young adults that are just trying to determine what they want to do with their lives. You always have the option of keeping the account open in your child’s name to continue to grow in value. If they decide later in life that they want to pursue a four-year degree, that money will be there for them. If higher education simply isn’t in the cards, you do have some other options.
- Change the beneficiary of the account. Most 529 plans allow you to change the beneficiary of a 529 plan once a year, as long as it stays within a family. Change the beneficiary to a sibling, cousin, grandparent, or parent and let them use the value for their own expenses.
- This allows for a lot of flexibility. If your spouse is interested in getting their degree or maybe taking some secondary classes, the 529 beneficiary can be changed to them. They can use some of the account, and then have the beneficiary changed back to the original holder or to another family member once they are done.
- Save for future generations. You can allow your child to keep the account in their name and have the beneficiary changed to their children in the future. The extra 20-plus years of gains will be significant and leave a solid nest egg for your grandchildren’s education!
You’ll pay taxes plus a penalty for non-education expenses
Non-qualified 529 plan withdrawals are taxed as income at your marginal rate, in addition to a 10% withdrawal penalty. But remember, these taxes are only on the gains in your 529 account. The deposits you made to your account over the years were made with after-tax money, which means that principle can’t be taxed again.
If you really just want to withdraw the money for your child to use to start a business, buy a house, or simply want to take the money out for your own retirement you can absolutely do so. However, I would run through the math to make sure you are comfortable with the money you are giving up to taxes first. If the money is coming out for your child, be sure to explain to them the tax loss as well.
The Math – 529 Plan versus Traditional Investment Account for a Child That Doesn’t Go to College
Stan’s parents have been saving for his college expenses since he was born. They put away $3,000 in a 529 plan every year and saw an average annual return of 5% with 0.4% fees. Stan’s parents have a household income of $110,000, meaning their marginal income tax rate is 25%.
Now that Stan is 18 and graduating high school, his 529 plan has $87,822 in it. However, Stan doesn’t want to go to college. Stan wants to become a mechanic and open his own small garage. He has found a technical school that offers full mechanic training for domestic and foreign cars. The program will take one full year and cost $24,000. After that, he has requested the rest of the money in his 529 plan be used to help him open his garage. Below is the step-by-step walk of the value of Stan’s 529 with his plan.
Now, if Stan’s parents hadn’t used a 529 plan and had instead started a traditional, taxable investment account to save for his future the withdrawals would have looked slightly different. His mechanic school would be more expensive since Stan’s parents would owe capital gains tax on the growth his account had seen, but the tax on the money for his new garage would have been lower.
With a traditional investment account, Stan would have just over $3,200 more for his garage than he does with the 529 plan. This makes sense as a 529 plan is built to benefit college expenses, not normal savings. Had Stan chosen to go to college and use the full value of his 529 plan for school, the 529 plan would be over $4,600 more valuable to him than a traditional, taxable account.
Should you use a 529 plan?
529 plans offer incredible benefits for a broad range of higher education expenses. The tax-free growth and high contribution limits make it a powerful tool. While Daddy Fish and I are far from certain on whether Fuss will go to college, we are aggressively saving in his 529. Our plan is to save enough for in-state college tuition, room & board in a 529 and keep any additional savings set aside for him in a taxable investment account in our name. The hope is that this blend gives us, and him, the best value for our savings.
It is impossible to know who our little people will grow up to be. When we start saving for their future we can’t know if they will want to be astrophysicists, firemen, teachers, or soldiers. But whatever they choose, the value of their 529 plan isn’t lost if they choose not to go to college. By starting to save early, they will have plenty of options.
Do you have a 529 plan for your child? Do you have a plan for the funds if they choose not to go? Let me know!
This post was proofread by Grammarly.